Mirror of Justice

A blog dedicated to the development of Catholic legal theory.
Affiliated with the Program on Church, State & Society at Notre Dame Law School.

Monday, October 5, 2009

I Wish I Could Shout "Amen!"

I appreciate Michael Perry's "Amen" to my post on The Wisdom of a "Liberal with Sanity."  I wish I could reciprocate it by shouting "Amen "to his post of Martin Marty's essay entitled "Evangelicaldom."  I'm afraid I can't though.  First, I think that Dr. Marty, whose work on church history I admire, doesn't understand evangelical Christian conservatives at all well, and his animosity towards them is so intense (his protestations to the contrary notwithstanding) that it consistently generates unjustifiably harsh judgments against them.  The essay itself is evidence of this.  Second, the essay is just too partisan.  Indeed, it is nearly mindlessly so.  Anyone who thinks that that judgment might be too harsh can test it by the simple expedient of transposing the essay into a critique of the left, including the religious left, substituting names like "Kennedy" or "Clinton" for "Ensign," and names like "Olbermann," "Maddow," "Maher," and "Garafalo" for "Beck," "Limbaugh," "Hannity," and "O'Reilly."  For Neal Gabler and his critique of conservative populism, substitute Charles Krauthammer and his critique of liberal messianism.  For moderate conservative David Brooks and his warnings to those to his right, substitute moderate liberal Stuart Taylor and his warnings to those to his left.  And so forth.  In short, two can play at this game--which is a pretty good sign that it's hardly a game worth playing.  In any event, it isn't likely to generate much illumination. It will do little more than provide opportunities for partisans on the opposing sides to take turns shouting "Amen!" 

A must-read book, forthcoming . . .

Now, this has little to do with "Catholic Legal Theory" (though we have talked often over the years about urbanism and the like), but . . . I am delighted to note the impending publication of this book, "Ordering the City," by the lovely and talented Prof. Nicole Stelle Garnett.

The Center for the Study of Law and Religion . . .

. . . has a (first-rate) new website.  Check it out.

Religious education and the Church's evangelizing mission

Here is a letter, from the Congregation for Catholic Education, to the presidents of the various bishops' conferences, on the mission, and importance of Catholic schools:

The nature and role of religious education in schools has become the object of debate. In some cases, it is now the object of new civil regulations, which tend to replace religious education with teaching about the religious phenomenon in a multi-denominational sense, or about religious ethics and culture – even in a way that contrasts with the choices and educational aims that parents and the Church intend for the formation of young people.

Therefore, by means of this Circular Letter addressed to the Presidents of Bishops’ Conferences, this Congregation for Catholic Education deems it necessary to recall some principles that are rooted in Church teaching, as clarification and instruction about the role of schools in the Catholic formation of young people, about the nature and identity of the Catholic school, about religious education in schools, and about the freedom of choice of school and confessional religious education. . . .

Read the whole thing.

Robby George on "The Moral Witness of the Catholic Church"

Read Robby's lecture, here:

 . . . In sum, if the Church is to honor the healthy secularity that has been called for by Pope Benedict XVI, her shepherds and pastors from the Pope himself on down must be, at times, quite bold in denouncing grave injustices and violations of the common good, and at other times self-restrained in speaking out about matters of public policy upon which Gospel principles by themselves do not resolve differences of opinion among reasonable and well-informed people of goodwill. . . .

Pope Benedict XVI on an "integrated education"

PB16 is speaking the good stuff.  Are our Catholic schools and universities listening?

. . .

The proper autonomy of a university, or indeed any educational institution, finds meaning in its accountability to the authority of truth. Nevertheless, that autonomy can be thwarted in a variety of ways. The great formative tradition, open to the transcendent, which stands at the base of universities across Europe, was in this land, and others, systematically subverted by the reductive ideology of materialism, the repression of religion and the suppression of the human spirit. In 1989, however, the world witnessed in dramatic ways the overthrow of a failed totalitarian ideology and the triumph of the human spirit. The yearning for freedom and truth is inalienably part of our common humanity. It can never be eliminated; and, as history has shown, it is denied at humanity's own peril. It is to this yearning that religious faith, the various arts, philosophy, theology and other scientific disciplines, each with its own method, seek to respond, both on the level of disciplined reflection and on the level of a sound praxis. . . .

Lumen Christi Institute: The Imago Dei

This conference-event, sponsored by the Lumen Christi Institute in Chicago, looks great.

Christianity Today: "Rome Won't Give Up on Europe Without a Fight"

Here's an appreciative article in Christianity Today, the evangelical magazine, on the Pope's campaign to win back Europe by preaching "basic Christianity" (an evocative term for evangelicals).  Among the thoughts:

Benedict seeks to mend an open wound in Europe politicians have not been able to heal. Secularism offers European nations no basis for relating to or confronting the highly religious immigrant populations now settling in their cities. Skeptics may rightly wonder whether church history offers a better way of coping with pluralism, given Europe's experience with interdenominational warfare. But Benedict deserves credit for steering the church back to basic Christianity in hopes of reminding Europe that the gospel of Jesus Christ once turned a barbarous continent into the cradle of Western civilization.

Catholics and health care reform

NCR, 10/5/09

What the church teaches on health care reform

Quick post from the Camino and its many blessings

Four quick notes.  First, I still get choked up when some of the Spaniards along the Camino greet me with a smile and a ¨Buen Camino¨(good camino/way/Journey) as I walk.  Second, I offered the day for a specific person and his family and all who are deeply wounded, suffering depression, doubt, hopelessness, or emptiness.  Third, I was sitting in the bar/cafe writing in my journal after arriving in Naverette (in La Riojo - left Naverre today) when two pilgrims who I have seen but don´t know their names gave me a glass of wine from the bottle they had just purchased.  A little later a Spanish pilgrim, Francisco, who speaks little English and who I have seen several days now, invited me to a dinner of his making at our Albergue.  I bought a bottle of Rioja tinto to bring to the party.  Fourth, and most amazing, as I was walking into Naverette, I saw a pilgrim with a duffel bag slung over his right shoulder.  I thought that seemed an odd way to carry your stuff.  He also seemed to be ailing from blisters by the way he walked.  He sat to drink some water in some shade and as I passed him, I asked if he was ok, noting his seeming problem walking.  It was then that I noticed that he only had a stump for a left arm (is that the reason for no backback?)  He then showed me his leg - it was an artificial leg - so I guess no blisters on his feet.  I don´t know where he started and whether he is going all the way to Santiago, but whether he is travelling for one day  or the whole way, he was an inspiration to me.