Mirror of Justice

A blog dedicated to the development of Catholic legal theory.
Affiliated with the Program on Church, State & Society at Notre Dame Law School.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Accountability Revisited

Russ, the comments section on your post is closed, so I am replying this way.  I think you have your facts wrong.  A 51 year old priest was arrested, NOT the Cardinal.  For all we know, the Cardinal exercised appropriate oversight and response, so it may be the case that your confidence is properly restored.

UPDATE:  Russ has now corrected his post.  We all make mistakes, and I have made my share of them.  I leave my post up rather than deleting it because quick and inaccurate moves to condemn the Church on this blog can have far reaching consequences as evidenced by the fact that a reader of this blog repeated Russ' innaccurate characterization of the facts on Facebook.    

Thursday, May 5, 2011

From Atheist to Catholic Thanks to Blessed JPII

The Washington Post recently ran a series on people impacted by the life of JPII.  Jennifer Fullwiler writes that the first time she took notice of JPII was during his funeral at a time when she was an atheist.  Two years later and much influenced by the late Pope's profound work, "Theology of the Body," Jennifer and and husband entered the Church.

HT:  Maria Ruiz Scaperlanda

Thursday, April 28, 2011

The Thunder Roll

The Oklahoma City Thunder won their first-ever playoff series last night, defeating the Denver Nuggets 4 games to 1 and now await either the Memphis Grizzlies or the San Antonio Spurs in Round 2. 

Connection to Catholic Legal Theory - well it's a stretch but here goes.  Kevin Durant signs himself before the start of each half.  And here is a great story on starting center Kendrick Perkins who served Mass from 7th grade through high school at Our Mother of Mercy Parish in Beaumont, Texas. 

Go Thunder!

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Conference on Catholic Legal Thought

We are honored that Oklahoma City's new Archbishop, Paul Coakely, will celebrate Mass for our conference at St. Thomas More University Parish at 5:30 pm on Tuesday, May 17.  The Mass is scheduled to take place right after what promises to be an enriching discussion with Paul Griffiths on the Essential St. Augustine for 21st Century Lawyers and Law Professors.

If you are attending the conference and haven't registered, please do so soon.  Thanks! 

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

6th Annual Conference on Catholic Legal Thought

See the attached schedule.  To request registration form please email Michael Scaperlanda at [email protected]

Download Schedule 2011

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Sixth Annual Conference on Catholic Legal Thought

The Sixth Annual Conference on Catholic Legal Thought will convene at the University of Oklahoma College of Law two months from today.  On May 17 we will spend the afternoon with Paul Griffiths, Warren Professor of Catholic Theology at Duke discussing "The Essential St. Augustine fr 21st Century Lawyers and Law Professors.  To facilitate the discussion we are asking participants to read "Augustine:  Political Writings," Adkins and Dodaro (eds), Cambridge Univ. Press 2001 and Books 2 & 19 from "The City of God."  On May 18 we will have sessions on "The City of Man:  What role should law play in infusing the City of Man with the City of God?" and "Forgiveness and Conversion: What should be law's attitude toward treatment of post-conviction criminals."  And, on May 19, Steven Smith, Warren Distinguished Professor of Law at San Diego wlll present his book, "The Disenchantment of Secular Purpose," which should be read in advance to prepare us for a robust discussion.

Next week, I will post the complete schedule along with registration material.

Monday, February 21, 2011

Bernard Nathanson, RIP

Bernard Nathanson has died at the age of 84.  After overseeing about 75,000 abortions, he became pro-life in 1979.

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Agriculture vs. Agribusiness

Mary Berry Smith chronicles her farm tour of Western Kentucky in an essay at Front Porch Republic. Here is a sample:

I would like to say a few things about the abuse of the farmer in the system. In contrast to the first farms we visited, the CAFO (Concentrated Animal Feed Operation) was markedly different. Three generations of a farm family were there—grandfather, father and grandson—but they never spoke. Their banker spoke, an extension agent and a representative from the companies that process the farmers’ chickens and hogs spoke.

...The representative from the pork company was truly astonishing. He told us that the farmer was a million dollars in debt to his company, and that the farmer’s profit was in the manure he could spread on his cornfields to sell to other farmers. (The problem of that manure is for another time.) He also exhorted us to tell others that these are great places and not to worry about pollution or disease because science would take care of it.

He actually suggested to us all the things there are to worry about in this system and then told us that science—the word “magic” could be substituted here—would solve all problems. He, of course, made the cheap food argument and the feeding-the-world argument, which I have come to regard as pure fantasy. You cannot make a case for feeding people by destroying the source of food. And anyone with any imagination could see that the same amount of meat could be produced in that area by having more farms and farmers raising animals in a sustainable way.

One way to revitalize small town and rural America would be to end federal subsidy and regulation that favor agribusiness over sustainable agriculture.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Small town America

I spent last weekend in a fairly small Nebraska town where my youngest is doing a two year teaching stint through Creighton's Magis program.  Charming with friendly inhabitants, I couldn't help but ponder the future of this and still smaller towns in a global economy.  The town's pharmacies and grocery stores have closed because they cannot compete with Walmart and Walgreens.  I assume, but don't know, that the farmers are dependent on agribusiness for their sustenance.  As banks consolidate, I assume some of the legal work (title work, etc) have moved to Omaha or Lincoln. 

Are there models for building thriving and dynamic small rural communities given the market conditions today that don't involve antique stores or becoming the location for a Walmart distribution center? 

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

"Religious Companies"

10 Religious companies (besides Chick-fil-A).  Call me skeptical!

UPDATE:  For the real deal, check out Our Project