Thursday, October 8, 2015
"Wolf Hall" gets Cromwell (and More, and the Church, and the Reformation . . .) wrong
Alfred Thomas explains, at Commonweal:
. . . Cromwell . . . presided over the creation of a Tudor police state aimed at imposing conformity through terror. More than three hundred religious dissidents were executed between 1532 and 1540, years coterminous with Cromwell’s tenure. Yet in Wolf Hall we have Cromwell assuring other characters (and thus the audience) that “we do not do such things”—by which he presumably means torture. If his contention was simply presented as political spin—if we saw him practicing what he says he doesn’t do—that would be one thing. But in fact we never do see Cromwell torturing his victims, whereas Thomas More is shown positively relishing the experience.
. . . [I]nviting viewers to identify with a man who enabled Henry to tyrannize his subjects and force on them a religion they didn’t want is ethically problematic. The show comes perilously close to reproducing the Whiggish view of the Reformation as a much-needed sweeping away of a corrupt and outdated form of medieval Catholicism.
For more on "Wolf Hall's" inaccuracies (and clear anti-Catholic agenda), see this, this, and this.
https://mirrorofjustice.blogs.com/mirrorofjustice/2015/10/wolf-hall-gets-cromwell-and-more-and-the-church-and-the-reformation-wrong.html