A thought about the "disenchantment of the world"

Yesterday, at a very interesting roundtable conference at Valparaiso University on Brad Gregory's new book, The Unintended Reformation, on participant recounted -- in the context of a conversation about Weber's "disenchantment" claim -- an exchange in which it was asked, "do you think you live -- that is, do you experience yourself as living -- 'in Creation' or in 'the Universe'?"   A big question, that.