Mirror of Justice

A blog dedicated to the development of Catholic legal theory.
Affiliated with the Program on Church, State & Society at Notre Dame Law School.

Monday, November 22, 2010

"Licensing Families"

Here's the nutshell, from Amazon, on a new book called "Licensing Families":

In Licensing Parents, Michael McFall argues that political structures, economics, education, racism, and sexism are secondary in importance to the inequality caused by families, and that the family plays the primary role in a child's acquisition of a sense of justice. He demonstrates that examination of the family is necessary in political philosophy and that informal structures (families) and considerations (character formation) must be taken seriously. McFall advocates a threshold that should be accepted by all political philosophers: children should not be severely abused or neglected because child maltreatment often causes deep and irreparable individual and societal harm. The implications of this threshold are revolutionary, but this is not recognized fully because no philosophical book has systematically considered the ethical or political ramifications of child maltreatment. By exposing a tension between the rights of children and adults, McFall reveals pervasive ageism; parental rights usually trump children's rights, and this is often justified because children are not fully autonomous. Yet parental rights should not always trump children's rights. Ethics and political philosophy are not only about rights, but also about duties - especially when considering potential parents who are unable or unwilling to provide minimally decent nurturance. While contemporary political philosophy focuses on adult rights, McFall examines systems whereby the interests and rights of children and parents are better balanced. This entails exploring when parental rights are defeasible and defending the ethics of licensing parents, whereby some people are precluded from rearing children. He argues that, if a sense of justice is largely developed in childhood, parents directly influence the character of future generations of adults in political society. A completely stable and well-ordered society needs stable and psychologically healthy citizens in addition to just laws, and McFall demonstrates how parental love and healthy families can help achieve this.

This sounds like a book that moves from some premises that are clearly correct -- e.g., "parents influence the character of future generations of adults" -- and moves to some conclusions and proposals that might be less attractive.  But, of course, I have not read it.  Others?

For my own thoughts on some of the matters that (apparently) this book covers, check out this paper.

https://mirrorofjustice.blogs.com/mirrorofjustice/2010/11/licensing-families.html

| Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515a9a69e20134896f0c71970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference "Licensing Families" :

Comments


                                                        Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Mr. McFall has a highly developed sense of irony. Toward the goal of inculcating in the children a lively sense of justice, we have to deny justice to the adults and confer upon the chosen parents a sense of inherent superiority which they will no doubt be expected to transmit to their offspring.

But he aims too low. He hasnt' just solved the problem of injustice, he has solved the problem of sin. If we licensed only sinless people to bear children, in a few short generations we would... Ah. I can see it already. Are those the lights of the heavenly city over there?