Mirror of Justice

A blog dedicated to the development of Catholic legal theory.
Affiliated with the Program on Church, State & Society at Notre Dame Law School.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Welcome, Arbp. Dolan!

I went to mass today at St. Patrick's Cathedral.  New York's new archbishop, Timothy Dolan, presided.  Wow!  What an engaging, warm, and inspiring person.  A wonderful (providentially so?) face for the American bishops, and for American Catholics generally.

Language matters, redux

As if to underscore Rob's point in this post, the ever-irenic (not) Frank Rich went off today.  Much of the column was devoted to tinfoil-hattery about Prof. Robert George and Princeton's James Madison Program.  (I was -- I confess! -- speaking on Friday at a conference on religious liberty co-sponsored by the Program.  I don't *feel* like a bigot. . . .)  He also trotted out the tired charge that to worry about judicial overreach is to set oneself against Brown v. Board of Ed.  (I imagine our own Michael Perry would -- as would, I am confident, if he could, that scourge of judicial overreach, Abraham Lincoln -- argue otherwise!).

Now, that said, I suspect that Rich is right, and that the movement toward same-sex marriage will continue, notwithstanding the current opposition of most people.  I do wonder, though, whether it will continue in a way that respects religious liberty.  (Should it?)  Rich's column does not provide much reason for optimism.  Stay tuned.

Habemus Papam!

Today is the 4th anniversary of Pope Benedict XVI's election.  Ad multos annos!

A Tree Grows in Oklahoma City

Re Michael S.'s reminder  of the anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing: while visiting them last spring, Michael and his wife, Maria, took me to visit the site.  Many things about the visit moved me, but one of most powerful parts of the experience for me was the American Elm tree standing on the plaza, called the "Survivor Tree" becuase it remarkably continues to grow despite its proximity to so much that was destroyed in the bombing.  During this Easter season, it stands as a wonderful reminder of resurrection.  I talk a bit about the symbolism of the tree in a reflection I posted here.

We will never forget

those who died and those who were injured 14 years ago today in the Oklahoma City bombing and those who came to aid them.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

"I dreamed a dream"

Over 26 million people have now viewed the youtube video of Susan Boyle singing "I Dreamed a Dream" on the show "Britain's Got Talent.  Catholic News Service reports

The audience snickered and the judges of "Britain's Got Talent" either rolled their eyes or allowed their blank expressions to betray their bemused skepticism as the awkward-looking middle-aged woman told them she wanted to be as famous as the popular British actress and singer Elaine Paige.

Then Susan Boyle began to sing, and they were spellbound and shocked by the beauty of her voice and rose to their feet in applause.

But Father Basil Clark, who watched the show on television at his home in Broxburn, Scotland, was not surprised.

He has seen the situation unfold many times before, having regularly accompanied Boyle, 47, on the annual Legion of Mary pilgrimage to the Marian shrine in Knock, Ireland.

"When I watched the judges' faces it reminded me of what I was like when I first saw Susan singing -- absolutely blown away by the quality of the singing and by that fantastic voice," said Father Clark, dean of West Lothian, the district that covers Boyle's home village of Blackburn.

For the rest of the story, click on the link above.  For the video click here.

UPDATE:  James Martin, S.J. writes (click here for the full post) on America's blog:

The way we see Susan Boyle is very nearly the way God sees us: worthwhile, special, talented, unique, beautiful.  The world generally looks askance at people like Susan Boyle, if it sees them at all.  Without classic good looks, without work, without a spouse, living in a small town, people like Susan Boyle may not seem particularly "important."  But God sees the real person, and understands the value of each individual's gifts: rich or poor, young or old, single or married, matron or movie star, lucky or unlucky in life.  God knows us.  And loves us.  

"Everybody is somebody" said Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan at his installation Mass in New York City yesterday.  That's another reason why the judges smile and the audience explodes in applause. 

Because they recognized a basic truth planted deep within them by God: Susan Boyle is somebody. 

Everybody is somebody.

Opening of the Fred T. Korematsu Center for Law and Equality

Today is the kick-off event for the Fred T. Korematsu Center for Law and Equality at Seattle University School of Law.  The presentations this morning focused on the Japanese internment, the initial Supreme Court decisions, and the later coram nobis decisions (nearly the entire legal team was present).  Speakers this afternoon will focus on the role of academics in advocacy for justice more generally.  The entire event was framed by Seattle University School of Law Dean Kellye Testy in the context of the obligations to love and do justice in Catholic tradition.  Please follow the link below for more information.

Korematsu Center Launch

Friday, April 17, 2009

Doug Kmiec on the Colbert Report, Discussing, Inter Alia, "Gay Marriage"

Check it out, via dotCommonwealHere.

Obama and Embryonic Stem Cell Research: The Influence of Gene Outka and Doug Kmiec?

NYT, 4/18/09

Some Restrictions Lifted on Stem Cell Research

WASHINGTON — The Obama Administration announced Friday that it planned to lift some — but not all — of the financing restrictions on human embryonic stem cell research in place during the Bush administration, a move that will please many but not all scientists.

The proposed guideline, which the administration plans to finalize by July 7, would allow research only on stem cells derived from surplus embryos at fertility clinics. Federal financing could still not be used to support the creation of embryos solely for the purposes of research or embryos created by therapeutic cloning.

Such restrictions, some scientists believe, could limit research into the creation of genetically matched organs for transplantation. And in an odd twist, the guideline’s requirements that donors be told what might happen to their embryos during research may make ineligible for future federal financing some of the older stem cell lines that President Bush had approved.

[The rest is here.]

Consider the position of Gene Outka, Dwight Professor of Philosophy and Christian Ethics at Yale University.  Outka "take[s] conception and all that it alone makes possible as the point at which one should ascribe a judgment of irreducible value" and opposes the creation of embryos for use in stem cell research.  But Outka would permit the use of "excess" embryos, i.e., embryos left over after infertility treatments have been completed.  See Gene Outka, "The Ethics of Human Stem Cell Research," in Brent Waters & Ronald Cole-Turner, eds., God and the Embryo:  Religious Voices on Stem Cell and Cloning 29 (2003).  (The quoted language is on p. 55.)

The GOP & Same-Sex Marriage (and More on Tony Blair)


April 17, 2009, 9:51 am

Top G.O.P. Consultant Endorses Gay Marriage

If Steve Schmidt is for same-sex marriage, can Senate Republicans be far behind?

Well, yes. We don’t expect establishment Republicans in Washington — or establishment Democrats, for that matter — to suddenly endorse gay marriage. But in a possible sign of the momentum of the gay-marriage movement, Mr. Schmidt, who was a senior adviser to the Republican presidential nominee, Senator John McCain, last year, is promoting gay marriage this afternoon.

He endorsed same-sex marriage last month, in an interview with the Washington Blade.

Today, Mr. Schmidt, who also served as a top Bush aide, discusses the subject with the Log Cabin Republicans, a group that supports gay rights. According to CNN, he will call on conservative Republicans to drop their opposition at a lunchtime speech in Washington.

Mr. Schmidt, who has a sister who is a lesbian, plans to say that there is nothing about gay marriage that is un-American or that threatens the rights of others and that in fact it is in line with conservative principles.

“There is a sound conservative argument to be made for same-sex marriage,” Mr. Schmidt plans to say, according to speech excerpts obtained by CNN. “I believe conservatives, more than liberals, insist that rights come with responsibilities. No other exercise of one’s liberty comes with greater responsibilities than marriage.’”

[The rest is here .]

[I posted something a few days ago about Catholic-convert Tony Blair's comments on the magisterial position on homosexuality.  This is from the April 18th edition of The Tablet:]

Mr Blair also asserted that most Catholics disagreed with the Pope when it came to homosexuality. "If you went and asked the congregation, I think you'd find that their faith is not to be found in those types of entrenched attitudes," he said.

A seasoned observer of Vatican affairs reported that these remarks had caused consternation in Rome because they were understood to imply that Mr Blair knew the Catholic world better than the Pope. "What really annoys people is the arrogance of dictating to the Pope and saying that his liberal class, liberal angle is more in tune with Catholics than the Vatican," said the source. There is a "huge tension between [Blair's] socially liberal politics and the Church he has joined - he has to square the circle of his views and his religion." A spokesman for Mr Blair told The Tablet this week that: "teaching and doctrine does evolve and is elaborated over time by successive generations".

Martin Pendergast, a steering group member of the Catholic caucus of the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement, who coordinates twice-a-month Masses for London's lesbian and gay Catholic community, thought Mr Blair had been right. "Tony Blair has simply echoed the views of many ordinary Catholics in this country, particularly those who have lesbian or gay family members," said Mr Pendergast. "As on many other contemporary issues, the Vatican becomes more and more isolated in its rhetoric, even from many of its priests and bishops."

James Alison, a Dominican theologian who has written on gay issues, said: "It was a breath of fresh air for it to be said in public what we all know: the Catholic faithful are by and large much more relaxed and friendly about gay people than is our clerical structure."

[The whole piece is here.]