First Things: Immigration and the Bishops

With the lack of political will for a national solution, more states are adopting ever more strict immigration legislation, targeting those illegally here and those who interact with the undocumented.  Some of these laws pose potential threats to the sacramental, pastoral, and social life of the Church.  And, some of these laws may be unjust towards the objects of the legislation.  For these reasons, bishops and other church leaders have spoken out against these laws. 

In an opinion essay printed in the February 2008 First Things (subscription required), I critique the responses of Archbishop Beltran (Oklahoma City) and Bishop Slattery (Tulsa) to severe immigration legislation adopted last year in Oklahoma.  With the immigration issue, the Church has the opportunity to engage its own members and the broader culture with a rich and nuanced tradition.  It also has the opportunity to educate its own community and the broader culture as to the proper place of the Church in the broader society and the limits properly placed on attempts by the state to control and direct the Church.  My critique of Archbishop Beltran and Bishop Slattery is meant as constructive not only for them but for all bishops facing similar circumstances.  With limited staff working in extraordinary circumstances, they have responded admirably.  As we go forward, I hope all bishops build upon their foundation.    

I welcome your thoughts on my essay.