The Iraq War

Given the prominence of Just War Doctrine in Roman Catholic thought, it's at least a little surprising that there hasn't been more discussion here of the Bush Administrtration's decision in March 2003 to commence war against Iraq.  I'm sure that some of us supported and others of us opposed that decision.  I doubt that those of us who opposed the decision now think that our opposition as mistaken, but I suspect that some of us who supported the decision now think that our support was mistaken.  NYT columnist Tom Friedman is a prominent political liberal who supported the decision--and, so far as I am aware, he has not said that his support was mistaken.  Listen to some of what Friedman said in his column yesterday (9/8/06):

We are stalled in Iraq not because of something some fringe antiwar critics said, or did, but because of how the Bush team, the center of U.S. policy, approached Iraq from the start. While it told the public — correctly, in my view — that building one example of a tolerant, pluralistic, democratizing society in the heart of the Arab-Muslim world was really important in the broader war of ideas against violent radical Islam, the administration acted as though this would be easy and sacrifice-free.

Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld told us we are in the fight of our lives against a new Islamic fascism, and let’s have an unprecedented wartime tax cut and shrink our armed forces. They told us we are in the fight of our lives against a new Islamic fascism, but let’s send just enough troops to topple Saddam — and never control Iraq’s borders, its ammo dumps or its looters. They told us we are in the fight of our lives against a new Islamic fascism, but rather than bring Democrats and Republicans together in a national unity war coalition, let’s use the war as a wedge issue to embarrass Democrats, frighten voters and win elections. They told us we are in the fight of our lives against a new Islamic fascism — which is financed by our own oil purchases — but let’s not do one serious thing about ending our oil addiction.

Donald Rumsfeld demonizes war critics as “morally confused.” But it is the “moral confusion” at the heart of the Bush policy — a confusion between its important ends and insufficient means — that has hobbled us from the start. It truly, truly baffles me why a president who bet so much of his legacy on this project never gave it his best shot and tolerated so much incompetence. He summoned us to D-Day and gave us the moral equivalent of the invasion of Panama.
_______________
mp